Custom 5 Point Star Badges with Border

Quantity Discount on Western Badges:
MIX & MATCH badge styles.
Quantity Discount
5-9 $.50
10+ $1.00



STEP 1: Select your plating, packaging, and font options

STEP 2: Click on the "CUSTOMIZE HERE" tab

STEP 3: Enter in your text options

STEP 4: Create a custom story for inside the Kraft box lid (optional)

STEP 5: When finished click the green "CLICK HERE TO ADD CUSTOMIZATION" button

STEP 6: Click the "ADD TO CART" button


  • Once your order is placed we will email a sketch of your design. Please allow at least 24 hours and also check your spam folder. 
  • You will have at least 48 hours to respond to the sketch email with any changes.
  • The faster you approve the sketch the faster your order will ship.
  • We usually ship within 1-2 business days of sketch approval.
  • Please review our returns policy for custom made items.

Four packaging options are available

1 - No packaging

2 - Hang card packaging

3 - Leatherette Case

4 - Kraft box packaging with a stock or custom story option

Each high quality Old West replica badge is crafted out of brass and steel. They are double-stamped then silver plated. Next, each Old West replica badge is individually hand finished for a unique antique look. Individual badge finishes may differ (lighter or darker) from image shown.


These badges work great for weddings, birthdays, awards & recognitions, name badges, old west reenactments, Single Action Shooting Society (SASS) affiliated clubs, Cowboy Mounted Shooting Association (CMSA) clubs, costume accessories, or just for fun.

Size: approx. 3 1/8" H
Back: Vertical, light-duty bar style pin

Maximum:  25  chars.
Maximum:  25  chars.
Additional One Time Fee: $5.00
Maximum:  700  chars.
Maximum:  500  chars.

Backside Attachment

1 Butterfly Clutchback:
2 Butterfly Clutchbacks:
Verticle Bar Style Pin:


3 1/8" H
Very pleased and happy of the work : a very good item, made with care and quickly delivered ! Congratulations !
This badge is absolutely gorgeous, and looks and feels exactly authentic, like a perfect rendition of a real wild west badge. The lettering is perfect, and the badge came very quickly. The metal looks like real gold/brass, and has a heavy weight, like a real badge.
The badge is high quality and looks prestigious that I am proud to give one to my friends as a memento of our 100 mile mountain bike ride. The team at Pieces of History help make the ordering and custom engraving process easy, and my order with in the time they advised.
i give 5 stars
Very Nice Excellent service.
I was really happy with the badge purchase I made from this site it was personalized perfectly and is going to be used as a "best man" gift for my upcoming wedding!
Excellent quality for price. There were no defects or spelling mistakes, and the contrast of the black lettering on the silver plate is sharp and easy to read.
Excellent transaction all the way around! Quick shipping and the badge was absolutely perfect and higher quality than I expected. The engraving was exactly as requested. Thank you! Highly recommended.
As a square dance caller, for many years I've used a sheriff badge (found in the toy department of a big box mega retailer). Whether the participants are youth or adults, the badge conveys a sense of fun and authority. Misplaced it after a gig, and found the high-end commercial make-your-own badge for law enforcement. Their products are nice...a little too nice for my purposes. Pieces of History's "Custom Silver Star Badge" is just perfect. I had it engraved with my name on the upper ribbon, and DANCE CALLER on the lower. $20 is a very reasonable price for this item. And the turn-time was optimal; I decided to go for it the week of a big event. Needed the badge by Saturday, and it arrived Thursday. Highly recommend!
I ordered 2 custom sheriff badges. I must say they look great. They were correctly engraved and shipped quick. The quality is just fine. I am sure my father will truly enjoy this unique gift. Thanks.
Write a review