Custom Sheriff Badges

Quantity Discount on Western Badges:
MIX & MATCH badge styles.
Quantity Discount
5-9 $.50
10+ $1.00



**If you are having trouble adding the customization, please login/create account and the issue is resolved.  Also changing the plating from silver to bronze and back to silver also works**

STEP 1: Select your plating color & packaging option

STEP 2: Click on the "CUSTOMIZE HERE" tab

STEP 3: Enter in your text options

STEP 4: Create a custom story for inside the Kraft box lid (optional)

STEP 5: When finished click the green "CLICK HERE TO ADD CUSTOMIZATION" button

STEP 6: Click the "ADD TO CART" button


  • Once your order is placed we will email a sketch of your design. Please allow at least 24 hours and also check your spam folder. 
  • You will have at least 48 hours to respond to the sketch email with any changes.
  • The faster you approve the sketch the faster your order will ship.
  • We usually ship within 1-2 business days of sketch approval.
  • Please review our returns policy for custom made items.

Four packaging options are available

1 - No packaging

2 - Hang card packaging

3 - Leatherette Case

4 - Kraft box packaging with a stock or custom story option

Sheriff Badge stock story in the box:

As settlers of the west became the targets of Indians, bandits and thieves, they needed someone to protect them.

The Sheriffs were the principal keepers of order in the western territories and usually fit into one of two categories, the quick or the dead.

Each high quality Old West replica badge is crafted out of brass and steel. They are double-stamped then silver plated. Next, each Old West replica badge is individually hand finished for a unique antique look. Individual badge finishes may differ (lighter or darker) from image shown.

Size: approx. 3 1/8" H
Back: Vertical, light-duty bar style pin

Maximum:  25  chars.
+$1.00 includes 5 letters. Price per letter after included: $0.50
Maximum:  25  chars.
Additional One Time Fee: $5.00
Maximum:  700  chars.
Maximum:  500  chars.

Backside Attachment

1 Butterfly Clutchback:
2 Butterfly Clutchbacks:
Verticle Bar Style Pin:

Additional Info



3 1/8" H
The sheriff's badge was exactly what I ordered and was delivered promptly and on time. I would not hesitate to order other products from your company.
Great item, very high quality. A pleasure to work with, prompt response and clear communication.
I received the sheriff badge that I ordered for my little girl's birthday party very quickly. She is having a party themed around the Disney channel show "Sheriff Callie's Wild West", and this badge is perfect for her to wear with the other costume things she likes to put on when she is being the sheriff. The badge itself is extremely high quality and much more durable than a badge made out of pewter would be. When compared to the badges you normally find for children this badge is top notch and I believe it could even serve well with a cowboy action shooter's period correct clothing that they wear when they are having a shooting match.
I am a Restaurant owner in Burnsville Minnesota, I found this website that said they could make custom sheriff stars. I ordered two of them to start and was amazed at the quality!!! At our restaurant they are used as markers for our regular customers, when the customers saw there name on a sheriff star at the place they always sit, they were amazed that they were being recognized in this way and they were very pleased with the quality of the markers. I since have ordered several more for our other regular customers and each one of them are very impressed when they come in and find there place has been marked with a sheriff star. I am very very proud of the place markers and would recommend the quality to anyone. the detail is exceptional. Thank you Pieces of history for making my customers feel so special here at Colorado Station!!!!!
I was very satisfied with my purchase. I had called before placing the order and they answered all my questions. The quality of the engraved badges was very high for 22 characters. Delivery was right on time (a few days). I would recommend them for future purchases.
I am very happy with every thing that I buy from you. Very prompt and friendly service and you are always helpfully in your suggestions. I will be buying more from you. Special thanks to Cindy.
I am extremely happy with my badge, it looks great and gets many comments. It would be better if the ribbon was a little bigger. Very happy.
A well constructed, beautiful product that I would be proud to own and or give away as a gift as I am doing.
The sheriff badges were wonderful replicas. The custom engravings were excellent and the total product quality was beyond expectation. The badges were given as part of a western themed retirement package and the recipients were thrilled to have such wonderful mementos of the old west and we are constantly reminded of those "thrilling days of yesteryear." All aspects of the order and customer service communication was top notch.
Everythink was fine. Thanks a lot. We are very happy to have "something" original from the US. Greatings from Germany!
Write a review

What is on the back of the badge?

All of our western badges have a lightweight  bar style pin that is attached vertically. 


Can I get a discount by purchasing multiple badges?

Yes, we offer quantity discounts!  Discounts are listed near the ADD TO CART button. You can mix and match badge styles to reach discount levels.


I'd like to request a special finish or plating.  Is that possible?

No, all finishes/platings are done at the factory level and it is not possible for us to change it.  We cannot make antique badges shiny or vise versa.


Can I customize any badge?

No, the way you see the badge in the picture is how the badge is and it cannot be changed.  We do offer a line of badges that are blank for customization.  These badges can be engraved with your personal text or images in the designated engraving areas only.


What is “Double-Stamped” Brass?

A badge that is stamped out of brass first has a mold or die created for each side of the design. Next a block of brass is placed between the molds and the design is "double stamped" simultaneously on both sides using many tons of pressure. This process pushes and presses the brass up and out to form the badge.


Why Brass instead of Pewter?

Brass is stronger and more durable than pewter. Brass is an alloy metal of copper and zinc. Pewter is an alloy metal of primarily tin. Tin is a relatively soft metal and because of this pewter can scratch and bend easily.